9005.3 |
Assessment |
|
Research Question
(Clear, unambiguous) |
This "research proposal aims to study the
effects of education on the timing of first marriage in China for men and
women." The general idea of
asking if education influences marriage patterns of women differently then
men is sensible. Because marriage
generally occurs within localities, and perhaps class origin groups, this
will require careful controls or hierarchical analysis. To what degree this comparison concerns
gender inequality is not obvious. |
|
Relevant
Literature |
The references to
relevant scholarship are good. |
|
Causal Interpretations
(clear, all parts defined, mechanisms, controls, plausible) |
The initial discussion of possible causal
influences is okay, but you would want to develop this further into some
clear, distinct arguments, some complementary, some competing. A reasonable expectation would be that
varied causal forces are at work, and
among those that are opposing, which dominate will depend on conditions that
vary across regions, social groups, and time.
So, rather than looking for one overarching outcome, you will probably
want to see how the multiple causal strands interact with different results
under different circumstances. |
|
Data
(variables, sample, comparison) |
Again, you will have to
see exactly what data is available to you and how far it can take you toward
the resolution of the research questions. |
|
Research Value |
It is true that the research might give some
insights on the current state of gender inequality in China. More than that, it could provide insights
into the changing structure of the family and the meaning of marriage. |
|
Overall |
This is another
potentially good project that would need development, but particularly
depends on the availability of data that would support it. |
|
|
|
|
|
|