8113.3 |
Assessment |
|
Research Question
(Clear, unambiguous) |
"What causes that the time spending on
educational activities vary among older than 25 years old Americans? Possible
causal factors would be sex, educational level, employment status, income,
having children nor not. The analysis mainly aims to find the different
significance of those variables having impact on education-related
activities." Okay. Education-related activities is probably
too vague a category, because it can include overly diverse activities. Still, okay. |
|
Relevant
Literature |
Yes, much on education
does treat it as a rational investment activity, the worth of which is
indicated by economic achievements.
Part of the probable difficulty in the proposed study is that time
investments in "adult" education include both goal oriented
activities (like this MA program) and self-improvement or cultural aims
without any agenda for economic returns.
You would need to identify the literatures relevant to this. |
|
Causal Interpretations
(clear, all parts defined, mechanisms, controls, plausible) |
The discussion shows some thoughtfulness, but
you would need to go much further. You
have to consider the varied goals for educational activities and, indeed, the
varied nature of educational activities.
Is going to a museum or attending a lecture educational. Or will you restrict yourself to formal
education? If the latter, you need to
start out with this (and justify it in terms of the research goals). |
|
Data
(variables, sample, comparison) |
The ATUS seems a good
place to start, but it is not obvious to me how it has handled adult
education activities. The education
scoring seems oriented toward standard degree programs, where a fair amount
of adult education is not. Also, you
have to worry about online education. |
|
Research Value |
Actually, if you find something like this
interesting and no one
has done this kind of research, then it has value simply for adding to our
knowledge. |
|
Overall |
The projects goals and
strategy seem reasonable if the data will support the strategy. |
|
|
|
|
|
|