8113.2 |
Assessment |
|
Research Question (Clear, unambiguous) |
"In developing countries, ... Does
mother’s education level also cause variance in early childhood mortality
rates?" Okay, this is a
straightforward, empirical question (at least on the surface). |
|
Relevant
Literature |
The one article
mentioned is actually irrelevant to the
research question. What is
known about this? What is the
literature? |
|
Causal Interpretations
(clear, all parts defined, mechanisms, controls, plausible) |
Rather than just stating the hypothesis that
more educated women will have fewer infants dying, the causal assessment
should tell us why. What are the
mechanisms or reasons for this expected effect. The idea that religions will make a
difference in sub-Saharan Africa because of varied teaching on sanitary
conditions seems far fetched. The
other controls mentioned all make sense - perhaps more than education. You need to think through what the
empirical distribution of educational experiences is like in various regions. |
|
Data
(variables, sample, comparison) |
The DHS data seem
appropriate. This brief project
description does not show why the research would focus on the sub-Saharan
region. |
|
Research Value |
The discussion of the research value does not
seem to make much sense. If changing
education patterns is difficult, then we would not do this research to
further strategies for reducing infant mortality. So, what are the other reasons? |
|
Overall |
The research topic is
reasonable. However, its value as a
contribution depends on what scholarly research has already pursued this
topic. And the research plan needs
some careful thought about causality in the real world circumstances of the
places being studied. |
|
|
|
|
|
|