0796.3 | Assessment | |
Research Question (Clear, unambiguous) | The apparent research goal is to explain why people with mental health issues die earlier that those who do not. This is a potentially interesting question, but it is not obvious that it is a question appropriate for an MA thesis. | |
Relevant Literature | This was omitted. This is a topic where familiarity with the relevant literature would be crucial for knowing what is worth researching. It took about 2 minutes of searching to find a review article (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4461039/) from 2015 of what has been studied. | |
Causal Interpretations (clear, all parts defined, mechanisms, controls, plausible) | As the World Health Organization summarizes,
"The vast majority of these deaths are due to chronic physical medical
conditions such as cardiovascular, respiratory and infectious diseases, diabetes and hypertension." |
|
Data (variables, sample, comparison) | The references to data seem poorly focused. | |
Research Value | The explanation of mortality among the mentally ill is important. Unfortunately, there is little in this project outline to suggest ideas or plans that would discover anything useful. | |
Overall | As it stands, this does not appear to be either well thought through or manageable. | |