0240.2 |
Assessment |
|
Research Question
(Clear, unambiguous) |
"Does female political engagement promote
legalization of same-sex marriage?"
This sounds reasonable on the surface, but becomes less clear when we
look closely. Political engagement is
very ill-defined. Does this refer to
the proportion of women who vote (compared to men) or the proportion of
elected officials who are female or something else? Since legalization of same-sex marriage is
largely only a recent issue but women's political participation goes back
much further, the question needs more specification. |
|
Relevant
Literature |
There is a fair size
literature on gender differences in support for political issues that is
relevant. There is also a (smaller)
literature on the impact of women in legislatures. These are probably more important that the
narrower literature on differential support for gay marriage by gender. |
|
Causal Interpretations (clear, all
parts defined, mechanisms, controls, plausible) |
The general question of how and why same-sex
marriage went from anathema to legal support in a short time is
difficult. Teasing out a possible role
of women's political participation may be hard. To do so, you will have to develop a more
complex and nuanced set of causal possibilities than shown here. |
|
Data
(variables, sample, comparison) |
The apparent plan, from
the data listed, is to merge data into a set coded by country and year with
the proportion of female legislators and the legal status of gay
marriage. Presumably this would be
assessed with some kind of event history analysis or the like with the
intention of testing if countries with more elected women accept gay marriage
earlier. This seems a reasonable
approach at this level of analysis. It
is not clear if this level of analysis is ideal, but that is a different
question. |
|
Research Value |
Omitted in project outline, but the value seems
evident (unless someone else has already done something like this). |
|
Overall |
It is not clear to me
that the main question is theoretically likely or empirically answerable
(given the historical realities).
However, the question is a plausible one and the research design seems
a workable way to seek an answer. |
|
|
|
|
|
|