1897 |
Assessment |
Research Question |
The statement of the question is not as well-worded as would be
desirable, but the intent of the research question is fairly clear and seems
reasonable |
Relevant Literature |
This looks like a fair start on a literature review. You probably should look at some more
general work on the relationship between attitudes, political identities, and
voting on social issues. |
Causal Interpretations |
This calls for a considerably more detailed and nuanced analysis
of causal possibilities. Why expect
crime rates to matter? Does the
average voter track crime rates or have any idea what rates should be
interpreted as high or low in the U.S.?
What social mechanisms link crime rates to people's positions on
crime, punishment, and potentially gun control? What kinds of crime? How do media, political parties, and the
like come into play? |
Data |
The plan for data seems okay, if not yet fully developed. It is not clear why you would choose the
county level rather than something more refined. Voting results are commonly available at
much finer levels in urban areas, as is other data. Also, using aggregate data at any level to
explain political behavior involves a series of substantive and
methodological issues, so you need to review the appropriate literature on
such issues and show that you have an adequate solution. |
Research Value |
It is not obvious how this research will add to existing
research on support for gun control.
This should be the focus of the section on research value. |
Timetable |
okay |
|
|
Priorities for Developing a Full Draft |
Three
things stand out: how will this research go beyond existing findings?, what
are the causal processes in question?, and how can the proposed data address
the these goals? |
|
Miscellaneous Notes |
|
|
|