Home games are in Bold.
| Date | Team | Site | Time/Result |
| 10/9/99 | Monmouth University (a) | Wall (Farmingdale, NJ) | W 4-2 |
| 10/22/99 | CW Post (m,a) | Syossett Skating Acad. (Syosset, NY) | W 8-0 |
| 10/23/99 | Suffolk CC (m) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 11-2 |
| 10/24/99 | Columbia University (m) | MacKay Ice Arena (Englewood, NJ) | W 11-1 |
| 10/29/99 | William Paterson College (m,a) | MacKay Ice Arena (Englewood, NJ) | W 5-3 |
| 10/30/99 | Manhattan College (m) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 1-0 (f) |
| 11/5/99 | U. of Rochester (a-DI) | Genesee Valley Park (Rochester, NY) | L 6-2 |
| 11/6/99 | Temple University (a) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 12-2 |
| 11/13/99 | Fordham University (m) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 12-2 |
| 11/17/99 | SUNY-New Paltz (m,a) | Mid-Hudson CC (Poughkeepsie, NY) | W 11-1 |
| 11/20/99 | SUNY-Albany (m,a) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 5-4 |
| 12/4/99 | Monmouth University (a) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | T 7-7 |
| 12/12/99 | Central Conn. State U. (a) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 4-2 |
| winter break | |||
| 1/8/00 | Alumni Game | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | |
| 1/22/00 | Columbia University (m) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 10-0 |
| 1/23/00 | SUNY-Stonybrook (m,a) | The Rinks (Hauppague, NY) | W 4-3 |
| 1/29/00 | Wagner College (m) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 8-0 |
| 2/5/00 | Southern Conn. State U. (a) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 9-1 |
| 2/6/00 | Rider University (a) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 5-1 |
| 2/8/00 | Fordham University (m) | Hommocks (Larchmont, NY) | W 9-2 |
| 2/11/00 | Central Conn. State U. (a) | Champion Skating Ctr. (Cromwell, CT) | L 5-3 |
| 2/12/00 | Seton Hall University (m,a) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 15-5 |
| 2/19/00 | CCM (m) | Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 12-1 |
| 2/20/00 | Suffolk CC (m) | Sports Plus (Lake Grove, NY) | W 12-2 | 2/26/00 | MCHC Playoff Round 1 (m) vs. Seton Hall University |
Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 11-1 |
| 2/27/00 | MCHC Playoff Semifinals (m) vs. Montclair State |
Sky Rink @ Chelsea Piers | W 7-1 |
| 3/1/00 | ACHA Nationals vs. Michigan State | The Forum (Fishers, IN) | L 3-2 (OT) |
| 3/2/00 | ACHA Nationals vs. Colorado State | The Forum (Fishers, IN) | L 3-1 |
| 3/3/00 | ACHA Nationals vs. Indiana U. | The Forum (Fishers, IN) | L 7-4 |
| 3/5/00 | MCHC Playoff Championship
Game vs. SUNY-Stony Brook |
The Rinks (Hauppague, NY) | L 4-2 |