In June 1974, the United States and Panama agreed on a treaty after two rounds of negotiations. The following point allocations are taken from The Art and Science of Negotiation (1982) by Howard Raiffa:

 

Issue
United States
Panama
1 US defense rights
22
9
2 Use rights
22
15
3 Land and water
15
15
4 Expansion rights
14
3
5 Duration
11
15
6 Expansion routes
6
5
7 Compensation
4
11
8 Jurisdiction
2
7
9 US military rights
2
7
10 Defense role of Panama
2
13
Total
100
100

The United States wins on issues 1, 2, 4, and 6 (its points are underlined above), giving it 64 points (22 + 22 + 14 + 6), whereas Panama wins on issues 5, 7, 8, 9, and 10, giving it 53 points (15 + 11 + 7 + 7 + 13). The players tie on issue 3, which we initially give to the US for an initial allocation of 79 points.

Issue 3 has the smallest point ratio (15/15 = 1.0) and becomes the first issue used in the equitability adjustment. Let p denote the fraction of that issue that the US will retain, and (1-p) the proportion that Panama will retain; then p must satisfy the following equation

64 + 15p = 53 + 15(1 - p)

Solving for p, we find that p= 4/30 = 2/15. Thus, the United States should get 13.3 percent of its position (2 points), and Panama 86.7 percent of its position (13 points) on issue 3 to equalize their point totals. This results in the United States and Panama receiving each receiving 66 of their points.

Back to Examples.